The false promise of Indonesia’s economy

In politics, repetition is a vital a part of any marketing campaign. But for Indonesian voters, who go to the polls to elect a brand new president on February 14th, one pledge is beginning to sound just a little too acquainted. Candidates hoping to guide the world’s third-largest democracy have now, for the higher a part of 20 years, been vowing to boost the nation’s progress charge to 7%.

Joko Widodo, the outgoing president generally known as Jokowi, was elected on such a promise in 2014. So was his predecessor, Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono, who got here to workplace in 2004. This time, two of the three contenders are making related pledges. Ganjar Pranowo, former governor of Central Java, has a progress goal of seven%. Prabowo Subianto, Indonesia’s minister of defence and the front-runner, has recommended that double-digit progress is feasible.

picture: The Economist

So far, 20 years of guarantees have fallen brief. Indonesia’s financial system grew by round 5% final yr, near the typical charge over the previous 20 years. The nation’s final 7% enlargement was in 1996, the yr earlier than the Asian Financial Crisis (see chart 1). Since Indonesia’s transition to democracy in 1998, guarantees of upper progress have been much more widespread than the insurance policies that may encourage such a shift.

The outgoing president has achievements to flaunt. A decade in the past the nation was one of many “Fragile Five”, a gaggle of emerging-market economies weak to excessive rates of interest overseas and a powerful greenback. Today its present account is roughly balanced and its exterior money owed modest. After legislative and authorized pace bumps, Jokowi’s omnibus invoice, which cuts restrictions on international funding and simplifies licensing, lastly grew to become regulation final yr. Indonesia’s infrastructure has improved over the previous decade, helped by the development of hundreds of kilometres of roads.

Yet the federal government’s proudest achievement is its nickel-focused industrial coverage. The steel is utilized in electric-vehicle batteries, and Indonesia has the world’s largest deposits. Export of most uncooked ore has been banned since 2014, the intention being to pressure firms to course of and manufacture in Indonesia. BYD, Ford and Hyundai are among the many carmakers now investing within the nation. Exports of ferronickel, a processed type of the steel, rose from $83m in 2014 to $5.8bn in 2022.

Although openness to funding from each China and the West and an unlimited stockpile of an important battery steel is proving to be a robust mixture, there are dangers to the strategy. One is technological. Cullen Hendrix of the Peterson Institute for International Economics, a think-tank, notes that lithium-iron phosphate batteries, which comprise no nickel, are rising in popularity. Sodium-ion batteries, which want neither nickel nor lithium, may surpass each sorts. Last month JAC Motors, a Chinese carmaker backed by Volkswagen, a German one, delivered the primary business autos powered by sodium-ion batteries to clients.

There are additionally indicators that Indonesian policymakers are studying the incorrect classes from their nickel success. Despite apparent alternatives within the sunny archipelago, solar-power funding is suppressed by guidelines that panels should comprise a number of domestically produced supplies. Last yr TikTok, a short-form video platform, was prodded right into a shotgun tie-up with Tokopedia, an Indonesian e-commerce agency. It paid $840m for a 75% stake within the agency after new laws halted its personal e-commerce operations within the nation.

Moreover, Indonesian companies stay stifled by native laws, regardless of reforms launched by the omnibus regulation. Rules requiring imports to be screened at specific entry factors are equal to a 22% tariff, in response to analysis by the World Bank—greater than twice the South-East Asian common. Indeed, non-tariff obstacles impose prices equal to 60-130% of the price of computer systems, electronics and transport tools. The election marketing campaign has featured few concrete economic-policy proposals, however not one of the candidates has expressed any zeal for peeling again the nation’s many commerce restrictions.

Indonesia’s industrial coverage undermines officers after they search to draw buyers who don’t want the nation’s sources. Malaysia, Thailand and Vietnam, which place fewer restrictions on outdoors buyers, are extra apparent locations for corporations on the lookout for alternate options to Chinese manufacturing. As a consequence, Indonesia’s exports of electronics should not simply decrease than another massive financial system in South-East Asia; they’ve grown extra slowly, too (see chart 2). The share of Indonesian exports heading to America is decrease than in any of its native opponents.

Although Indonesia is a comparatively younger nation, by the point of the following presidential election in 2029 this tailwind may have disappeared. The nation’s dependency ratio—the variety of youngsters aged underneath 15 and adults over 65 per 100 working-age adults—will start to rise steadily from that yr. Without simpler makes an attempt to spice up the financial system, discuss of seven% progress will stay illusory.

For extra skilled evaluation of the most important tales in economics, finance and markets, signal as much as Money Talks, our weekly subscriber-only e-newsletter.