Three surprises that could inflame commodity markets in 2024

As Russia continues to pound Kyiv, Western sanctions are starting to cripple Arctic LNG 2, the aggressor’s largest gas-export challenge. In the Red Sea, via which 10% of the world’s seaborne oil travels, American forces are doing their greatest to repel drone assaults by Yemen’s Houthi rebels. On January third native protests shut down manufacturing at an important Libyan oilfield. A extreme drought within the Amazon dangers hampering maize shipments from Brazil, the world’s largest exporter of the grain.

picture: The Economist

And but, throughout commodity markets, calm in some way prevails. After a few years of double-digit rises, the Bloomberg Commodity index, a benchmark that covers raw-material costs, fell by greater than 10% in 2023 (see chart). Oil costs, at just a little underneath $80 a barrel, are down by 12% over the previous quarter and are subsequently effectively beneath the degrees of 2022. European fuel costs hover close to their lowest ranges in two years. Grains and metals are additionally low-cost. Pundits count on extra of the identical this yr. What, precisely, would it not take to rock markets?

After successive shocks infected costs within the early 2020s, markets have tailored. Demand, held again by suppressed consumption, has been comparatively restrained. But it’s the provide response to elevated costs, within the type of a rise in output and a reshuffling of commerce flows, that makes the world extra shockproof at the moment. Investors are relaxed as a result of provide ranges for a lot of commodities look higher than they’ve for the reason that late 2010s.

Take oil, for example. In 2023 elevated manufacturing from nations exterior the Organisation of the Petroleum Exporting Countries and its allies, a bunch often known as OPEC+, was ample to cowl the rise in world demand. This pushed the alliance to chop its output by some 2.2m barrels per day (b/d), an quantity equal to 2% of world provide, in a bid to maintain costs secure. Nevertheless, the market solely simply fell wanting surplus within the remaining quarter. Kpler, a knowledge agency, predicts a median oversupply of 550,000 b/d within the first 4 months of 2024, which might be sufficient to replenish shares by practically as a lot as they declined throughout the heated summer time months. New barrels will come from Brazil, Guyana and particularly America, the place effectivity beneficial properties are making up for a fall in rig depend.

In Europe manic shopping for for the reason that begin of Russia’s conflict and a gentle winter have helped maintain gas-storage ranges at round 90% of capability, effectively above the five-year common. Assuming regular climate and no large disruptions, they need to stay near 70% full by the top of March, predicts Rystad Energy, a consultancy, simply beating the European Commission’s goal of 45% by February 1st. Ample shares will maintain fuel costs down, not simply in Europe but additionally in Asia, in flip incentivising extra coal-to-gas switching in energy era in every single place. This will assist decrease coal costs already dulled by an enormous ramp-up in manufacturing in China and India.

Mined provide of lithium and nickel can also be booming; that of cobalt, a by-product of copper and nickel manufacturing, stays sturdy, dampening green-metal costs. Increased planting of grains and soyabeans (exterior Ukraine) and clement climate are prompting pundits to challenge report output in 2024-25, after a lush 2023-24. That will push the typical stocks-to-use ratio at meals exporters, a key determinant of costs, from 13% to 16%, a stage they final noticed in 2018-19, says Rabobank, a Dutch lender.

Abundant provide suggests a sedate first half of the yr. After that, surpluses might slim. Non-OPEC oil output might stage off. Delays at some American liquefaction-terminal initiatives, which had been initially set to begin exporting in 2024, will frustrate Europe’s efforts to restock fuel. Low grain costs will crush farmers’ margins, threatening planting. Markets shall be extra uncovered to shocks, of which three stand out: a pointy financial rebound, dangerous climate and army blow-ups.

Whether or not large economies keep away from a recession, the tempo of world development is anticipated to be gradual, implying modest development in raw-material demand. Inflation can also be anticipated to ebb, so commodities can have much less attraction as a monetary hedge. But a shock shouldn’t be unattainable. One seems much less probably in China, the standard bellwether of commodity markets, than in America, the place rates of interest would possibly quickly be minimize and an infrastructure splurge is gathering tempo. Liberum, a financial institution, calculates {that a} one-percentage-point rise in its forecast for annual world GDP development would increase commodities demand by 1.5%.

Freakish climate would have a deeper impression. Europe’s winter shouldn’t be over but, as evidenced by the chilly snap that has simply begun. A long-lasting freeze might power Europe to make use of an additional 30bn cubic metres of fuel, or 6-7% of its normal demand, Rystad reckons. That might push the area to compete extra aggressively with Asia for provides. A climatic shock can be extra disruptive nonetheless within the wheat markets, not least if it had been to have an effect on Russia, the biggest exporter, which has had bumper harvests since 2022. The larder to cowl shortfalls is emptying. Owing to rising consumption, which is about to hit information this season, world wheat shares are already headed for his or her lowest ranges since 2015-16.

What about conflict? Four-fifths of Russia’s meals exports are ferried throughout the Black Sea, as are 2m b/d of crude. Naval tit-for-tats might jolt costs, although rising output from OPEC+, and worldwide stress to guard meals shipments, would calm markets. Red Sea flare-ups, prompted maybe by a sustained American marketing campaign in opposition to the Houthis, might trigger a 15% spike in oil costs, says Jorge León of Rystad—although this will likely not final lengthy both. War involving Iran and different Gulf states, the place many of the unused manufacturing capability lies at the moment, is what would actually trigger chaos. The potential for terrifying costs of the kinds predicted in March 2022, when barrels at $200 appeared potential, might return.

It would take one thing excessive—or a combination of much less excessive however nonetheless unlikely occasions—to blindside commodity markets. That shouldn’t be fairly the solace it appears. They have been blindsided by equally inconceivable occasions a number of occasions this decade.

For extra skilled evaluation of the largest tales in economics, finance and markets, signal as much as Money Talks, our weekly subscriber-only e-newsletter.